The global export of caviar, the briny
eggs of sturgeon that is one of the most coveted and lucrative wildlife
products, was ordered halted on Tuesday under the international
convention that helps nations manage threatened species.
The suspension, called for by
the secretariat of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered
Species, was described as a temporary measure to compel nations that
still export caviar and other products from wild sturgeon to
demonstrate that their fishing practices are not pushing the remaining
fish populations toward extinction.
Exporting nations must
"ensure that the exploitation of sturgeon stocks is commercially and
environmentally sustainable over the long term," said Willem
Wijnstekers, the convention's secretary general.
The suspension
also bars signatory nations from importing sturgeon products. This
means that Western retailers would still be able to sell wild foreign
caviar they have already imported. But once that inventory is depleted,
consumers would most likely have to purchase farmed eggs, which are
generally regarded as less desirable, or eggs from limited domestic
supplies. In any event, the market would tighten.
Sturgeon -
primeval, long-lived and sometimes massive - are the vestiges of an
ancient line of fish. Their eggs and meat, and the trade that surrounds
them, have become deeply entwined in the histories, cultures and
economies of the regions that produce them. Sturgeon products, legal
and illegal, are thought to be worth at least several hundred million
dollars each year, and perhaps much more.
But the remaining
sturgeon fisheries have all suffered from plummeting populations,
caused by dams that block spawning routes, pollution, excessive
fishing, corruption and highly organized black markets. And as a luxury
item in the West and among the newly rich in the post-Soviet states,
the fish and their eggs have become more valuable as they have become
more rare.
Caviar from beluga sturgeon, the most prized species, fetches more than $200 an ounce, roughly double the price of a year ago.
Scientists
and managers have noted that even before prices soared, there had been
several local extinctions of sturgeon, and many species, including some
in the United States, had been reduced to marginal populations.
Moreover, the remaining commercial stocks are the last reserves, a
condition that lent urgency to the secretariat's demand for more
thorough management plans. "We just have to get this right, because
there are not enough fish left," said David Morgan, head of the
secretariat's science unit.
The suspension covers all principal
areas that export wild sturgeon meat or eggs, including the Caspian
Sea, where 90 percent of the remaining trade originates; the Amur
River, on the Russian-Chinese border; the Black Sea and the lower
Danube.
It applies to 10 nations that still actively export
products: Azerbaijan, Bulgaria, China, Iran, Kazakhstan, Romania,
Russia, Serbia and Montenegro, Turkmenistan and Ukraine, the
secretariat said. The convention covers exports only, meaning fish
caught in each country can still be sold on domestic markets.
But
the main importing nations - among them the United States, Britain,
France, Germany and Switzerland - are all parties to the 169-nation
convention and are expected to follow the secretariat's call to block
imports.
Susan Lieberman, director of the World Wildlife Fund's
global species programs, said she expected the United States, which in
2005 unilaterally banned the importation of beluga sturgeon products
under the Endangered Species Act, to accept the new rules.
The
United States Fish and Wildlife Service, which is charged with
enforcing the convention in the United States, did not publicly comment
on the secretariat's announcement.
There was little immediate reaction from exporters.
Russia,
which trades heavily in sturgeon products for domestic and foreign
markets, is on official holiday for New Year and Orthodox Christmas
celebrations. Its natural resource officials could not be reached.
Read this and more at: